Biology Letters

Locating, tracking, and intercepting objects is a fundamental behavior for many organisms. For instance, predators must track and capture erratically moving prey for their survival. Using the echolocating bat as a model species, we investigate how short-term changes in target motion predictability affect longer-term motor plans when tracking a prey item. We used a paradigm where prey motion is under experimental control, and then applied computational methods to characterize how target motion predictability influences short- and long-term behavioral control. We find that target motion predictability during the tracking phase of insect capture influences both short-term changes in sonar call control, as well as longer-term behavioral control for transitioning between hunting phases. For changes in immediate behavioral control, bats produce more bursts of calls at a higher rate when tracking unpredictable moving prey, an indication that the bat is collecting more information about the targets motion for unpredictable than predictable trials. In terms of longer-term behavioral control, target motion unpredictability delays the transition from tracking to capture phase behaviors. We suggest that the bat does this to collect more information about target motion to time the transition from tracking to capture behaviors for hunting success. Additionally, we find the effects of target motion unpredictability are first seen as changes in the vocal motor plan and then the auditory motor plan (ear motion), hinting at a sequencing of motor changes that warrant further investigation. SummaryWhen presented with a more challenging hunting task, bats will increase their production of bursts of calls at a higher rate and delay their transition into capture behaviors.

The population of Madagascar exhibits a globally unique combination of African and Asian genetic ancestries. Previous studies have described the admixture history of Madagascar at island-wide scales [1,2], but less focus has been paid to fine-scale population structure across the island. We present new genome-wide genetic data from 192 individuals sampled across five regions of Madagascar. We identify population structure at extremely fine spatial scales ([~]10 km) among the Merina of the central highlands. By analysing subpopulations separately, we found one Merina group exhibited similarity to coastal populations in f4 ratios, estimated admixture dates, and pairwise FST distances, while another group was similar to other highland individuals in the same measures. This fine-scale substructure is likely associated with historical coastal-to-highland migration during the 18th and 19th centuries. In contrast, we also observe macro-scale structure in estimated timing of admixture across the island, with southeastern coastal groups exhibiting the earliest estimated admixture timings, and northern groups exhibiting the latest. This pattern corroborates previous results [1,2], and may suggest differing histories of admixture timing among Malagasy populations. Our results emphasise the importance of deep micro-geographic sampling to complement macro-scale analysis when characterising demographic history.

Many perceptual skills improve with a few days of training. However, weeks or months of practice may be required to reach a level of expertise on complex tasks (Watson, 1980). Here, we explored how gerbils attain expertise on a difficult task: amplitude modulation (AM) rate discrimination at very shallow AM depths, similar to the depths used during vocal communication. Using an appetitive Go-Nogo procedure, we first trained 6 gerbils to perform an AM discrimination task (Nogo: 4 Hz; Go: 4.25-10 Hz) at a depth of 0 dB (re: 100% depth). Animals were then trained to perform AM discrimination at successively shallower depths, from -3 to -18 dB, requiring an average of 5-10 days of practice to reach a performance metric of d[≥]1 for each depth. Finally, we determined that AM discrimination thresholds were nearly identical between 0 to -12 dB, and only slightly elevated at -15 dB. Improvements in performance were accompanied by a large reduction in response time during procedural learning, and a gradual reduction of response time during perceptual learning, even as AM depth became shallower (i.e., more difficult). The shallowest depth at which gerbils displayed peak performance on the AM discrimination task is similar to their lowest AM depth detection thresholds. These results suggest performance on challenging auditory perceptual tasks require prolonged practice, and is accompanied by increased automaticity (i.e., lower response time) that stabilizes once expertise is achieved.

Sex ratio distorters (SRDs) are heritable elements that bias offspring sex ratios to enhance their transmission. In the terrestrial isopod Armadillidium vulgare, feminization of genetic males can occur through vertical transmission of the sex ratio distorter known as the f-element, as well as through infection by Wolbachia, a maternally inherited bacterial endosymbiont that can alter host reproduction. Previous studies have focused on the distribution of SRDs and their associations with mitochondrial haplotypes in native European populations, but these patterns are poorly understood in the United States. In this study, we sampled A. vulgare in 12 states, screening individuals for Wolbachia infection, the presence of the f-element, and mitochondrial haplotypes. We found that Wolbachia shows a heterogeneous distribution across populations and haplotypes, in contrast with stronger associations in Europe. The f-element occurred in lower overall frequencies but showed a strong association with mitochondrial haplotype VI. These results indicate that patterns associated with SRD differ from those observed in Europe and suggest that multiple introductions and population mixing have shaped these distributions.

Animal weapons are ecologically important traits that mediate contests over limiting resources and can strongly influence survival and reproduction. Weapon traits often exhibit substantial intraspecific morphological diversity, raising questions about the ecological drivers of this variation. Acrorhagi are weapons produced by sea anemones that are used in intraspecific territorial encounters. Although acrorhagial morphology varies widely within species, patterns of intraspecific variation remain poorly characterized, and the extent to which such variation reflects differences in local intraspecific competition is unclear. Here, we conduct morphometric analyses to characterize within-population variation and allometry in acrorhagial traits of the solitary anemone Anthopleura sola. We show that these traits covary with habitats differing in conspecific density. The number of acrorhagi scaled positively with body size, and individuals occupying a high-density habitat tended to possess more acrorhagi than did similar sized individuals from a low-density habitat. In addition, anemones from high-density habitats exhibited longer acrorhagial cnidae, a pattern that was not explained by differences in body size or acrorhagial density. Together, these results suggest that competitive context influences weapon-related traits at multiple levels of biological organization, potentially via phenotypic plasticity or selective processes. More broadly, our findings highlight how fine-scale ecological variation may contribute to the maintenance of trait diversity within and across species.

Many primates exhibit female philopatry and live in stable, female-bonded social groups. Permanent group fusions are rarely documented in these populations. We present a case study on a fusion of two social groups from a hybrid population of baboons (Papio cynocephalus x P. anubis) living in the Amboseli basin of Kenya. The fusion occurred following a period of increased human-induced mortality in one of the two social groups. After the fusion, females from the smaller group became the lowest ranking. We compared female behavior in the months following the fusion to the behavior of females in groups that had not fused and also compared pre- and post-fusion fitness outcomes. Following the fusion, the groups activity budget and patterns of agonistic interactions were typical for the study population. Females preferred familiar grooming partners for a short period following the fusion; however, after three months, patterns in female grooming were comparable to other groups, indicating rapid social integration. With the caveat that our sample size was limited, we observed no detectable fitness-related costs of group fusion in terms of birth rates or offspring survival, and adult female mortality was low following the fusion. These results demonstrate the flexibility of female baboons in navigating exposure to novel same-sex conspecifics despite a species-typic pattern of female philopatry. Based on this and previous examples of group fusions, we propose that group fusions may be most likely to occur when groups are too small to retain adult males, defend against predators, or compete with other groups.

Whole genome duplication is a common mutation in eukaryotes with far-reaching phenotypic effects. The resulting morphological, physiological, and fitness consequences and how they affect the survival probability of newly polyploid lineages are intensively studied, but very little is known about the effect of genome doubling on the short-term evolvability of populations. Understanding the effect of polyploidization on the adaptive potential of populations is of crucial importance to predict the future of polyploid populations. In this paper, I investigate the immediate consequences of genome doubling on the genetic variance of populations. To do so, I performed numerical iterations and simulations of how the genetic variance of a quantitative trait changes after polyploidization, under different genetic architectures (additivity, dominance, and epistasis). I found that genetic variance generally decreases after genome doubling. Non-additive gene actions can make autotetraploid populations genetically more diverse than their diploid progenitors in rare cases, notably with overdominance and directional epistasis. By collecting estimates from the agronomic literature, I found that both dominance and epistatic variance contribute to the genetic variance of polyploid populations. These results bring new insights into the adaptive potential of newly formed tetraploid populations, and call for further experimental investigations of how polyploidization is associated with a short-term decrease in evolvability.

The Red Queen Hypothesis proposes that genetic variation is maintained in populations through antagonistic coevolution of hosts and parasites. A major assumption of the Red Queen Hypothesis is tight genetic specificity for infection. However, it has been argued that this genetic interaction of host and parasite (GHxGP) is sensitive to environmental context (GHxGPxE). Environmental change could accordingly disrupt coevolutionary oscillations on relevant time scales, calling into question antagonistic coevolution as a general and robust explanation for the maintenance of genetic diversity. To evaluate this critique, we used the plant-parasitic nematode Meloidogyne arenaria and its natural bacterial parasite Pasteuria penetrans to determine if specificity is altered by temperature. We exposed six isofemale host lines to five parasite sources at three ecologically relevant temperatures. We found that, at two of three temperatures, susceptibility to infection depended on the specific combination of host line and parasite source (GHxGP). This specificity varied across temperatures, consistent with a GHxGPxE effect. This three-way interaction was driven both by quantitative changes in the strength of specificity across temperatures and shifts in the susceptibility rankings of host-parasite combinations. Our study contributes a rare experimental test of a proposed challenge to the Red Queen Hypothesis and suggests the potential for environmental context to change host-parasite specificity.

Multimodal communication plays a central role in animal behavior, particularly when individuals must integrate information from different sensory channels to make rapid decisions. In aquatic environments, chemical and visual cues differ markedly in their spatial and temporal properties, such that chemical signals may be constrained by limited spatial resolution and temporal instability, potentially requiring visual information to reliably guide social decisions. In decapod crustaceans, both cue types are known to mediate reproduction, yet their relative contribution to mate-location behavior remains unclear. Here, we tested how visual and chemical cues from males influence mate-location behavior in females of the prawn Macrobrachium rosenbergii. Females were placed in a central arena and exposed to four stimulus configurations combining visual cues (a life-size photograph of a male or a control background) and chemical cues (water from an aquarium with or without a male). Attraction was quantified as the time spent in each half of the arena. Females showed no directional preference when exposed to chemical cues alone or when visual and chemical cues were spatially incongruent. In contrast, females spent significantly more time near male-associated stimuli only when visual and chemical cues were spatially congruent. These results indicate that mate-location behavior in this species depends on multimodal integration with a strong contextual dependence on visual information, which appears to gate the effectiveness of chemical cues. Spatially congruent multimodal signals are therefore necessary to guide orientation during mate search, suggesting that disruption of visual or chemical information in aquaculture systems may impair mating efficiency.

Bdelloid rotifers are known to survive desiccation and high doses of ionizing radiation. This extreme resistance is notably due to their capacity to cope with numerous DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). Genes encoding key components of the non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) DNA repair pathway are strongly upregulated in the bdelloid rotifer Adineta vaga following exposure to ionizing radiation. Considering the notably high doses tolerated by these organisms, their capacity to efficiently restore genome integrity is particularly striking. Although NHEJ is generally regarded as less accurate than homologous recombination (HR), the absence of major genomic rearrangements in the descendants of irradiated rotifers suggests that DNA repair occurs with high fidelity. Terwagne et al. recently reported a delayed repair in germline nuclei, occurring during oocyte development when homologous chromosomes pair, thereby enabling template-based repair through HR. In this study, we established an in situ hybridization approach on A. vaga cryosections to investigate the spatial and temporal expression of key actors involved in NHEJ, HR, and Base excision repair (BER) pathways in somatic and germline tissues. We show that NHEJ (KU80) and BER-related genes (PARPs) as well as A. vaga Ligase E (putatively involved in DNA repair) are expressed early after radiation exposure in the somatic syncytium. In contrast, HR-related genes (Rad51: two paralogs, Rad54), as well as PCNA (involved in DNA replication, NER, BER, HR) are expressed later in maturing oocytes, indicating the activation of a delayed homologous recombination repair pathway in germline nuclei. Nurse cells, which express genes associated with both HR and NHEJ pathways, may rely on both mechanisms for their own DNA repair while also supplying mRNAs to the maturing oocyte. Our results provide new evidence for a differential regulation of DNA DSB repair pathways between soma and germline in bdelloids, with NHEJ predominating in somatic tissues and HR in the germline of A. vaga. O_FIG O_LINKSMALLFIG WIDTH=200 HEIGHT=200 SRC="FIGDIR/small/722046v1_ufig1.gif" ALT="Figure 1"> View larger version (35K): org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@3b1f3borg.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@17f5eb5org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@122ef14org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@7e4413_HPS_FORMAT_FIGEXP M_FIG O_FLOATNOAbstract Figure:C_FLOATNO Summary of in situ hybridization results: genes coding for actors of NHEJ are expressed in the somatic nuclei and in the nurse nuclei of Adineta vaga individuals 2.5 hours post X-rays radiation, while genes coding for HR actors and PCNA (involved in multiple pathways including DNA replication and DNA repair: NER, BER, MR, HR) are expressed in the nurse nuclei 2.5 hours post radiation, and later in the maturing oocyte during oogenesis and in the laid eggs. Genes coding for actors highly expressed post-radiation, involved in the BER pathway appear to be only expressed in the somatic syncytium 2.5 hours post radiation, as well as the gene coding for the Ligase E, likely involved in DNA repair. C_FIG

Background and AimsPlants deploy triterpenoid saponins as chemical defences against herbivores, yet it remains unclear whether insect digestion detoxifies these compounds or generates equally or more active metabolites. Because saponin bioactivity depends strongly on glycosylation patterns, we examined the fate and defensive activity of hederagenin-derived saponins during herbivory. MethodsLarvae of Plutella xylostella were fed leaf discs containing structurally defined hederagenin-derived saponins. Saponin composition in treated leaves and larval frass was analysed by LC- qTOF-ESI-MS/MS. Feeding assays were used to compare the antifeedant activity of mono- and bidesmosidic forms. Key ResultsLarvae selectively metabolized complex hederagenin-derived saponins into simpler forms, with cellobiosides converted into monoglucosides during digestion, resulting in a marked shift in saponin composition between ingested material and frass. Feeding assays showed that monodesmosidic saponins strongly deterrer feeding, whereas bidesmosidic saponins were largely inactive. The loss of activity in bidesmosidic saponins was not explained by differential metabolism, indicating that glycosylation patterns directly determine biological function. ConclusionsInsect herbivores selectively modify saponin structures through deglycosylation, thereby altering their defensive properties. Our findings demonstrate that glycosylation governs both saponin activity and metabolic fate, highlighting insect-driven turnover as a critical component of plant chemical defence during plant-herbivore interactions. Issue SectionOriginal article

O_LITerrestrial insects are vulnerable to desiccation due to their small body size. Because insects lose most water through cuticular evaporation, cuticular traits strongly influence desiccation tolerance. Individuals with greater cuticular melanisation, i.e., darker ones, are hypothesised to tolerate desiccation better than less melanised ones. C_LIO_LIIn many butterflies, pupal colour is plastic - individuals pupating on leaves tend to be greener, while those that pupate away from leaves (off-leaf), such as on tree bark or defoliated twigs, tend to be browner. Brown pupae are hypothesised to have more cuticular melanin and are expected to experience higher desiccation stress than leaf-borne green pupae. Thus, plasticity in pupal melanisation may be an adaptation against desiccation. We tested this in the butterfly Eurema blanda. C_LIO_LIWe demonstrate that individuals pupating on on-leaf substrates are greener than those pupating on off-leaf substrates, and that desiccation stress is higher in the off-leaf substrates, a microenvironment typical of brown pupae, than in typical green pupae. Using Raman spectroscopy, we show that brown, but not green, pupal cuticles contain melanin. C_LIO_LIFollowing this, we obtained greener and browner pupae by manipulating substrate colour. When subjected to desiccation stress, browner pupae survived better than greener ones. There was no correlation between pupal colour and survival in the absence of desiccation stress. Thus, melanisation appears to confer a survival advantage to pupae by increasing desiccation tolerance. C_LIO_LISurvival under desiccating conditions was inversely related to water loss. Interestingly, melanisation did not correlate with water loss, suggesting that melanisation helps tolerate desiccation through physiological mechanisms not directly related to water loss reduction. C_LIO_LIOur findings reveal an additional, crucial, adaptive value of pupal colour plasticity, a trait that has been studied primarily from an anti-predatory perspective. C_LI

Arboreal insects have developed various strategies to navigate their discontinuous habitats. Many insects, including leafhoppers, katydids, and praying mantises, exhibit the ability to actively leap across their leafy platforms and land on a distant substrate. This behavior is especially important for non-winged insects, including nymphal forms of winged insects, which cannot fly between these substrates. To make a targeted jump, an animal must first orient towards the target, estimate the target distance and angular location, and jump with the appropriate take-off speeds and angles to land on their intended substrate. In three-dimensional space, jumping from one point to another requires estimating distance, as well as azimuthal and elevational angles. Jumping insects such as mantises typically reorient their bodies on the substrate to align with the azimuthal direction of the target. This behavior effectively reduces the task to a two-dimensional problem, in which they must estimate only the distance to the target and its elevational angle. Many insects, including praying mantises, perform rhythmic lateral head movements called peering before performing a targeted jump. Although previous studies suggest that mechanisms such as motion parallax while peering are used for distance estimation, the full repertoire of behaviors that enable mantises to jump to arbitrarily located substrates remains unclear. We hypothesized that mantises have distinct behaviors for distance and elevation angle estimation, which enable them to independently modulate their take-off speeds and angles before jumping. To test this hypothesis, we developed behavioral assays in which mantises were placed on a launch platform and jumped to a target platform positioned at variable distances and angles. Using this apparatus, we filmed the jumps of Giant Asian mantis nymphs (Hierodula spp.) with high-speed videography and tracked body parts to quantify take-off speed and angle. Because mantis jumps are ballistic, their trajectories can be modeled as projectile motion. Our results indicate that mantises estimate target distance and elevation angle using two separate behavioral strategies: distance is assessed through peering maneuvers that generate motion parallax, whereas elevation angle is determined through visual fixation of the target accompanied by specific postural adjustments. By combining these behaviors, mantises modulate the magnitude and direction of propulsive force to achieve successful jumps.

Behaviour is a key yet often overlooked component of animal camouflage and how it evolves alongside colour and morphology remains poorly understood. The repeated evolution of stick-like postures in spiders offers a useful framework for investigating the importance of behaviour for concealment, since matching the environment should rely on specific body forms and postures, not just colouration. We hypothesised that when spiders behaviourally align their body with the background orientation it should influence the shape, posture and colouration that best enhances camouflage. To test this, we used a genetic algorithm and human observers to evolve digital spiders to be harder to find. We evaluated how selection under three behavioural orientation treatments (aligned, random, and evolvable orientation) influenced spider capture time, background match (lightness and colour), posture, and body (cephalothorax and abdomen) dimensions. We found that spiders that behaviourally aligned with the background took substantially longer to find through evolving a better background match, and a more elongated posture and body shape than randomly orientated spiders. Our spiders mirrored the shape and posture adopted by numerous clades, illustrating how behavioural camouflage represents a key concealment strategy in structurally complex habitats, part of an interacting suite of traits that encompass successful concealment.

In most species, unmated individuals run the risk of dying with zero fitness. This strong selection on virgin females to mate may also explain why females subsequently remate, despite fitness costs; all that is required is a genetic correlation between virgin and non-virgin mating propensity. Despite being the null model for the evolution and maintenance of polyandry, this hypothesis has received no empirical test. We performed separate quantitative genetic and artificial selection experiments to test the presence of this cross-context genetic correlation in the cow-pea weevil, Callosobruchus maculatus. A quantitative genetic experiment did not find evidence of the hypothesised genetic correlation. However, after 13 generations of artificial selection on virgin mating latency, we found strong evidence for evolutionary divergence in remating latency. Females from lines selected for longer virgin mating latency took approximately twice as long to remate and, were less polyandrous if their virgin mating latency was longer. There was no evidence that females could mate indiscriminately and then trade-up, rather, trading up could only occur if virgin discrimination was present. Selection against virgin death will thus constrain both the evolution of non-virgin discrimination and trading up, increasing rates of polyandry. These findings reveal a genetic correlation between virgin and non-virgin latency to mate suggesting that polyandry may be maintained because of the need to breed.

Animals continuously evaluate environmental cues to guide approach-avoidance decisions, with internal states like hunger dynamically shaping how stimuli are acted upon. While most studies examine the valence-switching of stimuli from appetitive to aversive using simplified or ambiguous stimuli, we leveraged a system in which a single prey contains both appetitive and aversive features. The nudibranch Berghia stephanieae, is a specialist predator of the sea anemone, Exaiptasia diaphana. These nudibranchs must resolve conflicting signals where chemical cues signal food, while contact can result in injury or death. The danger posed by Exaiptasia was described and quantified through direct counts of nematocysts fired into Berghia and multiple instances where the Berghia was captured and consumed by its prey. To test how internal state influenced the perception of stimuli from prey we recorded predatory behavior of Berghia after different periods of food deprivation. We found that the olfactory cues from prey were attractive to Berghia, even when animals were sated, and usually led to a contact-mediated investigation of prey. Hunger independently modulated olfactory and contact cue valence at different internal states and time scales of food deprivation. Hunger specifically altered the threshold for avoidance following contact with prey, indicating that somatosensory and chemotactile cues are modulated by hunger unlike olfactory cues. Our results highlight how internal state and sensory modality interact to shape decision making in a biologically relevant, high-risk predation context.

Within species, individuals of the same age can differ in size. Previously, parental genetics, nutrition, space, and social interactions have been suggested to explain different growth rates. However, direct effects of larger individuals on the physiology and growth of smaller individuals are poorly understood. In this study, we investigated how larger individuals of the marine worm Platynereis dumerilii can impact the growth of smaller conspecifics. Comparing growth distributions in communally and individually reared worms, we show that larger worms suppress the growth of smaller ones. Furthermore, we were able to demonstrate that this suppression is chemically mediated. The chemical cue does not originate from faeces but is water soluble, stable for several days and smaller than 3 kDa. Our findings highlight the importance of non-reproduction related chemical signalling, showing evidence that dominant individuals can chemically suppress the growth of their conspecifics. This study provides new insights into how hierarchy can be established and maintained in a population and is particularly relevant for the growing community studying this model species.

Vole and lemming population cycles are an enigma in ecology. Decades of field observations and experimental manipulations have revealed that cycles cannot always be explained by extrinsic factors in the environment, including food availability or predator numbers. Thus, it has been proposed that intrinsic mechanisms, such as adaptive alterations in phenotype during different phases of the cycle, drive population dynamics. However, the mechanisms underlying such phenotypic changes have not been elucidated. We test the hypothesis that epigenetic changes occur over population cycles by comparing whole epigenome DNA methylation changes in brain tissue collected from northern red-backed voles (Clethrionomys rutilus) in a wild, naturally cycling population during the peak, decline, and low years. Overall, the greatest number of differentially methylated CG sites (DMCs) and differentially methylated regions (DMRs) were detected in comparisons between voles from the peak phase and low phase of the cycle. We highlight methylation differences in the promoter region of ATP synthase subunit c (Atp5g3) and an intron of insulin-like growth factor 1 receptor (Igf1R), which may be associated with growth, development, and bioenergetics. There were additional changes in the promoters of members of the cytochrome P450 enzyme family, including Cyp1a1, associated with estrogen metabolism, as well as the promoter of macrophage migration inhibitory factor (Mif), and in an exon of serum/glucocorticoid regulated kinase (Sgk1), which may link changes in stressors to direct brain changes. Our study is the first interrogation into broad epigenetic changes associated with natural population cycle phase in a wild mammal.

BackgroundEnvironmental conditions shape the evolutionary trajectories of RNA viruses, yet little is known about how complex physical stressors such as microgravity influence host-virus interactions and viral evolution. Here, we investigated the short-term evolutionary consequences of simulated microgravity on the Caenorhabditis elegans - Orsay virus (OrV) system. MethodsOrV was subjected to six serial passages in hosts acclimated to low-shear modeled microgravity, with parallel evolution under standard-gravity. Evolutionary outcomes were evaluated using virulence, transmission, and replication traits, all measured under standard-gravity conditions. ResultsViral load fluctuated across passages in both environments, with lower mean accumulation in microgravity-evolved lineages. After evolution, we detected no significant changes in virulence. Transmission increased in standard-gravity lineages but not in microgravity-evolved ones, while viral replication decreased in all lineages, with a stronger decline in those evolved under microgravity. However, the magnitude of phenotypic changes was generally modest. DiscussionThese results indicate that evolution under microgravity can alter viral phenotypic trajectories over short timescales. However, because all traits were assayed under standard-gravity conditions, we cannot directly assess local adaptation to microgravity, and the observed differences may reflect environment-specific trade-offs rather than reduced fitness per se. Furthermore, the limited number of passages and the modest magnitude of phenotypic change suggest that evolutionary responses may still be in an early stage. ConclusionOverall, our findings provide initial evidence that simulated microgravity can influence the evolutionary dynamics of an RNA virus, while highlighting the need for reciprocal fitness assays and longer-term experiments to fully characterize adaptation to altered gravitational environments.

There is disagreement on whether secondary endosymbionts are found in the major cereal pest aphid, Rhopalosiphum padi. Some papers report a diversity of secondary bacterial endosymbionts while others have failed to find evidence of these bacteria in this species. Here we revisit this issue by summarizing the relevant literature and through additional sampling of the species in Australia, China and Denmark using a combination of molecular approaches. We find a general absence of secondary endosymbionts beyond the obligate endosymbiont Hamiltonella defensa in R. padi. While the inconsistency in survey results may reflect rapid changes in endosymbiont turnover in populations and/or the impact of ecological factors such as host plant type on endosymbiont diversity, we are concerned that technical issues may be at least partly responsible for inconsistencies in the literature. This leads us to emphasize the importance of multiple sources of evidence required to establish and characterize endosymbiont infections, including PCR and qPCR assays, DNA Sanger sequencing and 16SrRNA gene metabarcoding. We note that several major aphid pests show a low incidence of secondary endosymbionts which raises issues about the importance of these endosymbionts in aphids that constitute pests, even though endosymbionts can in some cases increase host fitness and therefore pest impact.